Seeing Presidents Putin and Trump sitting alongside President Xi of China provoked an interesting question in one of our recent leadership workshops: Does the hubris that comes with reaching the very top make us more susceptible to dumb decision-making?
5-minute read – 100% written by humans.
The evidence is troubling. Most of us will never lead a country, but as we become more senior, we are vulnerable to the same fallacies and thought distortions that accompany power and influence. The good news is that there are some practical steps we can take to protect the quality of our judgment, especially when under pressure.
There are arguably many things that Trump and Putin have in common. But two stand out: Both seek to project an air of invincibility to those who surround them. Both have led their countries into ill-judged wars with consequences that they did not foresee. What characterized the buildup to both Putin’s adventurism in Ukraine and Trump’s bombing of Iran, was the absence of dissenting advisors who should have provided a counterweight.
In the main, leaders don’t typically arrive on the scene convinced of their infallibility. It’s a distortion that evolves over time.
Deaf to the ‘ground truth’
Repeatedly, we see leaders gradually surround them with the gutless, the sycophant and the self-preservationist. This invariably happens at the expense of the courageous and plain speaking. Others observe what’s happening and soon learn the unspoken rules of the game. The result is that senior leaders fail to hear the reality; either because people won’t tell them or they are simply deaf to the ‘ground truth’.
On the flip side, many historians believe that JFK’s humiliation over the Bay of Pigs fiasco early in his presidency meant he was more open to advice during the Cuban Missile Crisis. It could have been an example of a little humility literally saving the world.
Belief in their infallibility
In business, as leaders climb the corporate ladder they become more susceptible to the belief in their own infallibility. A stroll around the cemetery of once-great corporations would provide a salutary lesson in the dangers of hubris. Carved onto the headstones will be the names of CEOs who were undone by a refusal to listen to the advice of those around them.
Take the example of Nokia’s leadership, who persisted with smartphone development plans that were increasingly detached from what the company could deliver in reality. As a result, the world’s dominant mobile phone manufacturer lost its leading position in the smartphone market. The rest is history.
Researchers Timo Vuori and Quy Huy interviewed Nokia managers and discovered a climate of fear. Middle managers were reluctant to tell senior executives about technical problems and unrealistic deadlines. Information was filtered, and progress reports became increasingly optimistic.
One manager described how people knew things were going wrong but saw little benefit in telling senior management. The researchers concluded that fear distorted communication and impaired Nokia’s ability to respond to the iPhone.
The simple fact is that creating a speak-up culture is the most effective prophylactic against doing dumb stuff. The corporate world can learn from the healthcare sector.
Learning from healthcare
Let’s take the case of Elaine Bromley, who checked into a hospital for a routine sinus operation. Some nine days later her husband took the decision to turn off her life support machine.
At first, all seemed to be going to plan with the procedure. Elaine was being cared for by a very experienced anesthetist. She was given an injection to relax her facial muscles. At this point her airway collapsed.
The anesthetist and the consultant surgeon set about intubation, a standard procedure in these cases, which entails inserting a tube though the mouth and into the throat to ventilate the lungs.
But the intubation wasn’t as straightforward as it should have been; both the anesthetist and the surgeon struggled. After 2 minutes of struggling, the intubation was still not successful, and the patient’s oxygen level had fallen to 75%. After 4 minutes, Elaine’s level of oxygen had fallen to 40%, which is potentially fatal.
At one point there were three experienced surgeons attempting the intubation procedure.
After 6 to 8 minutes Elaine’s heart rate was dropping rapidly. At this point, recognizing what needed to be done, a Nurse called for an emergency tracheotomy set. The solution seemed obvious. A tracheotomy is a common procedure for ventilation by making small incision through the neck directly into the windpipe.
A colleague arrived seconds later with a tracheotomy set. He stood by the door. He was ignored by the three senior consultants. Assuming he was no longer needed, he left. In fact, there was already a tracheotomy set in the theater anyway.
After 10 minutes the patient was turning blue. Another nurse who had just entered theatre spotted this. She quickly called colleagues in intensive care. Could they have a bed ready for her? They could, great! She ran to tell the team of surgeons that intensive care was ready for the patient.
Then in her own words:
“They looked at me as if I were mad… as if to say what’s your problem.”
The nurse cancelled the bed.
As the surgeons continued to struggle. Elaine had been at an oxygenation level of 40% for over 20 minutes. Damage will be irreversible.
Why hadn’t they listened?
Why did such an experienced and expert team fail to take the obvious steps? Why – in the heat of the moment – hadn’t the senior consultants listened to their junior colleagues?
The story has a further twist. Elaine’s husband, Martin, is an airline pilot. He recognized the parallels with the aviation industry where radical steps had been taken to improve the likelihood that junior crew members speak up to their senior colleagues when they recognize a high-potential safety issue.
Analysis in the aviation sector had identified that the lack of a speak-up culture in the cockpit had contributed to numerous fatal crashes. The more people tended to be deferential to senior colleagues, the greater the risk. So – all crew had been put through CRM (Crew Resource Management Training.) It focuses on effective communication and decision-making, not least on how to assertively communicate concerns to senior colleagues.
Getting junior team members to change their behaviour is only one part of the equation. The bigger question is what should leaders do differently if they are to create a culture where it feels genuinely safe to speak up?
Admit when you have made the wrong call.
Rachel Pack from the University of Western Ontario, and Lauren Columbus, from McMaster University and their colleagues sought to find this out. They then shared their insights in their exquisitely titled paper. “Maybe I’m not that approachable.”
They set up an obstetrics scenario with one of the obstetricians being part of the research team. But this was of course unknown to the rest of the participants. The scenarios involved scripted clinical judgement areas or professional infractions.
The aim was to understand the circumstances under which people feel more inclined to question the judgment of the seniors. All aspects of the teams’ behaviour were recorded on video, then followed up with interviews and analysis of transcripts. The scenarios were repeated 13 times, involving their 39 participants.
Their findings closely matched what we tell the leaders we train at Threshold:
- Actively make yourself available and be truly present when you are available.
- Be prepared to show you’re not always certain by sharing your thinking and think aloud.
- Debrief with the team openly and honestly and be prepared to show your vulnerability in the debrief… Above all, be prepared to admit mistakes.
The willingness of leaders to admit mistakes turns out to be a remarkably strong determinant of psychological safety.
Our October 2026 YouGov research, involving approximately 2,000 UK employees, found that where senior leaders openly acknowledge their mistakes, employees are 11 times more likely to say that different perspectives are genuinely considered in decisions and 8 times more likely to feel safe disagreeing with senior colleagues.
The differences are striking: 69% versus 6% for having different perspectives considered and 72% versus 9% for feeling safe to disagree.
When was the last time you admitted making the wrong call about something in front of your team?

To find out how we can help leaders in your organisation to be more impactful, influential and persuasive visit www.threshold.co.uk



